Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 28
  1. #1
    Moderator KK20's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    my heart at the sea and my soul in the mountains
    Posts
    14,326

    Default The lingering, unspoken pain of white youth who fought for apartheid

    https://theconversation.com/the-ling...partheid-46218
    The legacies of apartheid in South Africa can only be understood by making sense of the complexities of the past. This includes recognising what those who were young during the apartheid era - and who are now the elders and leaders of our society - experienced during that time.

    In the roughly 30 years between the Sharpeville massacre and the 1994 democratic elections that ended apartheid, a generation of Southern Africans faced challenging and often conflicting choices about ideological allegiances.

    For young white boys, the end of their school careers came with a choice about responding to the “call-up” to the South African Defence Force (SADF). This system of military conscription was instituted in 1957 by the apartheid government and became compulsory from 1968 onwards.

    Military conscription was key in the apartheid state’s “total response” to what was construed as a “total onslaught” by the perceived threats of communism and African nationalism. The state tried to draw white society into supporting this campaign by invoking a generations-long tradition of men doing military service to protect their country, values and families.

    The end of apartheid meant this was the last generation of white South African and South West African (now Namibian) families to send their young men off to war in such large numbers. The very different dynamics of contemporary South Africa make it hard to understand the scale of pressure these young men experienced at home, in many churches and in most social and political domains. White South African society was politically conservative and deeply invested in protecting its interests. Democratic notions such as freedom of choice were almost unheard of. Calls of duty and service were paramount.

    The impact that the system of conscription had on the roughly 600,000 white men, or 7.1% of the roughly 4.2 million white people in South Africa in 1992, who became both pawns and agents of the apartheid state, has seldom been publicly acknowledged in post-apartheid South Africa.

    Duty and conscience

    Those who accepted the call-up received rigorous military training, followed by deployment in South Africa, Namibia or Angola for the rest of their period of service. After that came several years of annual short-term “camps”. Over the 25 years that conscription was in place, service increased from nine months to a total of 720 days including camps.

    Military combat was rare until 1975, when the SADF invaded Angola after its Portuguese colonial government collapsed. This initiated 14 years of what became known as the “Border War”, consisting of intense military and guerrilla warfare in northern Namibia and southern Angola.

    There were harsh consequences for those who disobeyed the call-up. Their choices? A court martial and up to six years in prison, exile in another country or going into hiding in South Africa.

    University studies could delay military service, and some men exploited this for as long as possible. Conscientious objection (on religious rather than moral ethical or political grounds) became a legal option in the mid-1980s – around the time the End Conscription Campaign was established and began public campaigns in support of conscientious objectors as well as calling for an end to conscription.

    The war comes home

    White South African society lived in almost complete ignorance about the scale of the war and the SADF’s strategies. Most conscripts said little about what they experienced. This was partly because they had to sign the Official Secrets Act upon joining. It was also the result of the “willed ignorance” of most white South Africans and the draconian censorship laws of the time.

    In the mid-1980s, anti-apartheid resistance within South Africa intensified and SADF soldiers were deployed domestically. Suddenly, young white men were being called on to police fellow citizens by patrolling the racially defined borders between segregated communities. The “Border War” had come home.

    The unsustainable nature of the morally and economically bankrupt apartheid system became increasingly evident, even to apartheid’s leaders who initiated discussions with the then banned African National Congress (ANC) during this time.

    The ramifications were widespread. The war in Namibia and Angola ended with the 1989 withdrawal of the SADF from Namibia. Namibia gained independence a year later. The ANC and other organisations were unbanned, political prisoners released and the negotiations that led to the 1994 elections got under way.

    1994: A new era

    Conscription was officially disbanded in 1995, as was the SADF. A new integrated army was established - and conscription slipped into the realms of silence and memory for most people. For conscripts themselves, the memories of their time in the military haven’t faded. Some have embraced the possibilities of new freedoms while others have fought to maintain and celebrate historical identities in a changed context.

    There have been some efforts by the public and civil society to recognise the complexities of conscripts’ experiences, being both victims of a system and perpetrators in its name. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission held a special hearing on conscription. Increasing numbers of books about and by conscripts have been published. And several groups such as veterans, some NGOs and the Legacy of Apartheid Wars Project at Rhodes University have done some work around the issue, mostly in the form of research, public dialogues and workshops to address issues of woundedness and trauma - for conscripts and those who fought against apartheid.

    However, for the majority of conscripts, the [discursive laagers](http://www.researchgate.net/publicat...e_Border_Wars) that have shaped their social positioning remain intact. Most of the trauma they might have experienced remains unspoken or manifests in aggression, particularly when dealing with people, groups and situations they perceive to be a threat in some way.

    As the more complex dimensions of our apartheid history begin to emerge, the healing and transformative possibilities of stories about conscription surfacing in the public domain should not be underestimated - especially as a way of making sense of our deeply racially divided society.
    Last edited by KK20; 09-04-2019 at 16:08.
    live out your imagination , not your history.

  2. #2
    User
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Not where I want to be..
    Posts
    12,593

    Default Re: .

    I can identify with the narrative.

    It is always easy to look back decades later on situations like this and comment on the morality of the situation and the seriousness of what families and kids were made to endure. It was no joyride or frivolous escapade.

    I was 17 years old. My youngest son is 17 this year and this gives me a lot of food for contemplation........it was tough on those who were forced to be involved.

  3. #3
    Moderator KK20's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    my heart at the sea and my soul in the mountains
    Posts
    14,326

    Default Re: The lingering, unspoken pain of white youth who fought for apartheid

    I know of a family that had 4 sons. Three of them died on the border. I can only imagine what the mother went through when the youngest was called up. ( fortunately he was exempted from border duty because he lost 3 brothers before him)
    live out your imagination , not your history.

  4. #4

    Default Re: The lingering, unspoken pain of white youth who fought for apartheid

    Speaking purely personally, I wouldn't overcook it either. But it is very hard for people today to understand the dynamics of that time in history. The hardest part however has been the journey from "prisoner to freeman". By this I mean that apartheid imposed shackles on the mind, as much for the oppressor as for the oppressed. In many senses those who were part of the oppressor group were also victims. For them, the journey to freeing their minds of those mental shackles has not always been an easy one. It requires a significant degree of careful introspection and checking oneself and your own thinking and thought patterns on an ongoing basis; it requires a certain degree of brutal internal honesty. It also encompasses a broad sense of pain; of course there is the sense of loss of a particular time and place but it is less that than the sense of discovering fully and appreciating fully the hurt that has been imposed on others and that continues to this day and trying to come to terms with that in a way which leaves your own humanity still somewhat intact. I can't fully describe it all in a short paragraph...
    Quemadmodum gladius neminem occidit: occidentis telum est.

    Seneca (4 BC - 65 AD)

  5. #5
    Banned
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    Stella
    Age
    46
    Posts
    10,870

    Default Re: The lingering, unspoken pain of white youth who fought for apartheid

    Is there a precise and reliable count of the fallen on SA side during the Border War?

  6. #6
    User
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    BFN Freestate
    Age
    45
    Posts
    12,144

    Default Re: The lingering, unspoken pain of white youth who fought for apartheid

    In my family, and among the people I know/knew, there are a distinct difference even between conscripts. In that I mean people conscripted and trained by the army, deployed etc, and those that actually took part in war, been in the thick of things. The one group remembers conscription very fondly, often talk a lot of how good a time it were and how good the army were. The second group don't talk much. I dunno if that means or symbolizes anything, or if it's even any kind of norm, but for me it meant talking the talk is not the same as walking the walk.

  7. #7
    User
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    JHB
    Age
    41
    Posts
    2,980

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Ds J View Post
    Is there a precise and reliable count of the fallen on SA side during the Border War?
    Probably, but I've not seen an official number for all casualties.

    Also, which forces are we counting? SADF, UNITA, irregulars etc

  8. #8
    Banned
    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    Stella
    Age
    46
    Posts
    10,870

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Messor View Post
    In my family, and among the people I know/knew, there are a distinct difference even between conscripts. In that I mean people conscripted and trained by the army, deployed etc, and those that actually took part in war, been in the thick of things. The one group remembers conscription very fondly, often talk a lot of how good a time it were and how good the army were. The second group don't talk much. I dunno if that means or symbolizes anything, or if it's even any kind of norm, but for me it meant talking the talk is not the same as walking the walk.
    Now that you mention it, I have experienced both opinions in my daily work with the "war generation". Some folks remember it fondly, others seem to have been hurt severely. Sometimes it is a bit of both.

    One thing that is almost universal amongst ex-soldiers is a sense of loss - they feel it was a waste of time because everything they fought against happened non the less.

    I get the notion that going to war did not matter that much. What really hurts them is the waste it seems to have been. "The guys we were supposed to have shot are now our ministers" - or similar - is a sentence or feeling often heard.

  9. #9
    User
    Join Date
    Dec 2014
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    2,125

    Default Re: The lingering, unspoken pain of white youth who fought for apartheid

    Quote Originally Posted by Ds J View Post
    Is there a precise and reliable count of the fallen on SA side during the Border War?
    http://sadf.info/SADF%20Roll%20of%20...%20Border.html

    ^ The above are SADF casualties so exclude those of SWATF and SAP. I've never seen an official (i.e. governmental) count.

  10. #10
    User
    Join Date
    Mar 2018
    Location
    Verwoerdburg
    Posts
    308

    Default Re: The lingering, unspoken pain of white youth who fought for apartheid

    I see many sources stating that the border war started in the 1960's. There is a book written by a friend of mine called "Buffalo battalion" (Die Buffel struikel in Afr) that has perhaps the most insightful take on the war and the events that caused it. In The book the writer states that the border war actually began with the 1913/14 Rebellion when Jan Smuts forced SA men to annex German South West. This book is part of a trilogy together with "Rebelspoor" (about the 1913/14 rebellion itself) and "vang 'n Boer" (focusing more on the political/ideological aspects of PLAN/SAW/FNLA/etc) The last two are unfortunately only available in Afrikaans. I urge anyone who has an interest in the border war and the history of Southern Africa in general to read these books. Or at least Buffalo Battalion

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •