Section 16 motivations?

[Gleock]

Why would it be useless in the application stage? Let’s forget about the quality of many of the folk sitting at the CFR, but surely it should have some clout if included in your original application?

They are well aware of this judgement and the same clerk that disregards the PAJA docs is the person that is expected to consider this judgement.
There is no need to have this included in the original app to be able to use it at the appeals stage, so submitting this document and omitting a motivation will just increases your chance of ending up having to do an appeal.

Look, if you going to submit it and take it all the way to force them to abide by the judgement, by all means go for it.
It is going to be a short lived victory though, because the more they see this judgment being included in apps, it will just result in an amendment.

In my opinion, motivate (nobody said it needs to be a thesis) and keep this tool as a backup for an appeal, because including it doesn't guarantee anything in the application stage.

[curious george]

Administrative "justice" or "fairness" can't be mentioned in the same sentence as FCA and,or CFR.

[inanabhay]

I still do a "motivation Letter" - all of mine are less than 2 pages long - never had any issues with the applications

[piglet]

Just remember to sign your motivation, although not a requirement.
My app got denied even after a lawyer appealed.
O and my new app I had to sign every page

[M80BHP]

My apps included a short motivation explaining which Division I intend to shoot and why that gun is suitable for that division of IPSC...I have 2 approved and the last one is at 88 days....

[Bins]

SAPS case - 66325 2018 order received from court - 05.04.2019

"Johannes Douglas Richards vs National Commissioner"

Judge Ranchod

Draft order
"4. It is de
clared that section 16 of the Firearms Control Act 60 of 2000 makes no provision for any motivation to accompany an application. "

Can send you the pdf scan of the judgement if you need.

Hi please send me the judgement thanks

[JhbBoy]

Hi please send me the judgement thanks

Sure!

[Bins]

Hi Jhboy haven't received it hey

[Bins]

Hi Does anyone know if CFR is now in operation as they closed on 01/07/2020 for deep cleaning

[JhbBoy]

Hi Jhboy haven't received it hey

I was being facetious...want to give me your email address?